It was such an pointless scene that the author of the film felt the necessity to apologise later.
Some context: Within the scene, Eve’s character, Carol Marcus, and Captain Kirk are speaking about disarming a torpedo, and abruptly, Marcus decides a change of clothes is critical. She asks Kirk to show round, which he does however he takes a peek anyway, and we see Marcus in her underwear.
JJ Abrams, the director, then holds on that shot for a bit too lengthy and the best way it has been framed can be a lifeless giveaway of the scene’s intention – to cater to the majorly male Star Trek fandom. The shot was used within the trailer as nicely.
The film’s costume director, Michael Kaplan concurs:
Final time, Zoe wanted to put on underwear, and this time it was Alice Eve’s flip. , it is a slightly giant male fanbase, and JJ needed to enchantment to that.
Let’s be clear, this form of factor occurs on a regular basis, and it is one thing we’re accustomed to, particularity in films with a male target market. The issue was the way it was finished in Into Darkness; it was fully misplaced and took the viewers out of the film.
There was a lot adverse chatter on-line surrounding the scene and Damon Lindelof, who wrote the film, issued an apology whereas additionally considerably justifying the scene:
I copped to the truth that we should always have finished a greater job of not being gratuitous in our illustration of a barely clothed actress. We additionally had Kirk shirtless in underpants in each films, however I don’t need to make gentle of one thing that some construe as misogynistic. What I am saying is I hear you, I take accountability and shall be extra conscious sooner or later.
By and enormous, the objectification of women and men in films continues to be principally disproportionate. Now, a pre-emptive strike for the people who find themselves going to level out that Chris Hemsworth and Chris Pine are sexualised in Thor and Surprise Girl – Sure they’re, however here is the factor:
One may make the argument that since Thor is a God, it’s considerably related to bolster his energy and bodily prowess. As for Pine, that scene was pivotal to the story. It was the primary time Diana had seen a person undressed and it helped construct the sexual rigidity between the 2 characters. Furthermore, that scene additionally served as subversive tackle girls objectification in blockbuster films. Whereas in Into Darkness, Eve is diminished to an object for no good motive, apart from to enchantment to the male gaze.
There was unquestionably no want for this scene. It wasn’t related to the story in any approach in any respect. Nevertheless it’s heartening to listen to Lindelof’s phrases.
The underside line is, they do that as a result of it really works. What number of of you clicked on this reply due to the picture? And if finished proper, it may be entertaining (because it was in Surprise Girl), but it surely actually wasn’t finished proper in Into Darkness.