Hoax Story – The Muhammad Ali Underwater Training Hoax
Early in his career, Muhammad Ali convinced the media that he regularly trained underwater.
The Sept 8, 1961 issue of Life magazine featured a photo essay about a young boxer, 19-year-old Cassius Clay, who had an unusual training technique. He trained underwater.
Clay had recently won a gold medal in the 1960 Olympics, and since going pro he had won his first eight matches. He was also making a name for himself outside the ring as a charismatic and outspoken character.
In 1964 he would win the world heavyweight championship and change his name to Muhammad Ali, by which history remembers him better. But in 1961 Clay was busy training for his ninth match, against Alex Miteff who outweighed him by twenty pounds. However, Clay was confident that his underwater training would give him the edge in the ring. The text of the photo essay explained:
Clay did proceed to beat Miteff, knocking him out in the sixth round. So evidently the underwater training worked. Except, no. Clay didn’t train underwater. In reality, the photoshoot he did for Life was the one and only time he ever trained underwater. He had invented the story about underwater training as a stunt to get publicity.
However, for years no one questioned the claim about training underwater. It was simply accepted as part of the lore of Muhammad Ali. Until finally, around 1997, the photographer who did the photoshoot, Flip Schulke, revealed that Ali had invented the story.
In 1961, Sports Illustrated had assigned Schulke to take pictures of Clay. So Schulke traveled to Overtown, Florida where Clay was training.
When he first met Clay, Schulke tried to impress the young boxer by sharing examples of his work. For instance, Schulke revealed that he specialized in underwater photography and had recently had photos published in Life showing water-skiers from below the surface of the water.
Seeing these photos, Clay immediately told Schulke that it so happened that he trained underwater in a swimming pool because, “An old trainer up in Louisville told me that if I practice in the pool, the water resistance acts just like a weight.”
Clay demonstrated by jumping into the pool at the hotel where he was staying (The Sir John Hotel) and started to throw punches in the water.
Underwater training sounded plausible enough to Schulke, and he thought photos of it would make an interesting feature, so he pitched the idea to Sports Illustrated. But the editor there, as Schulke later said, “thought I was crazy for taking pictures of a boxer in a swimming pool.”
However, the editor also gave Schulke permission to pitch the idea to Life, saying, “Go ahead and ask Life if you want to. If they’re dumb enough to, let them do it.”
So Schulke called Life, and they liked the idea. Schulke proceeded with the photoshoot. The pictures ran in Life. And they became among the most celebrated sports photos of all time.
One of the pictures (below) from that shoot, showing Clay fully underwater with his fists raised, is one of the most famous pictures of Ali ever taken. But it didn’t run in Life because the editors there thought it looked too posed.
Schulke next met Clay three years later, after the boxer had won the world heavyweight championship. In his 2003 book Witness To Our Times Schulke described this meeting:
For another Muhammad Ali-related hoax, see Cassius Clay Wins Literary Prize (April 1, 1963).
- Ali Underwater
- Johnston, Paul. (Apr 15, 2016). “The Fascinating Story Behind Muhammad Ali’s Famous Underwater Photos.” Sothebys.com.
- Hirshon, Nicholas. (Aug 18, 2005). “How an underwater hoax spawned a sports legend.” New York Amsterdam News.
- Schudel, Matt. (July 20, 1997). “Where Ali Became The Greatest – In 1960, A Teen-Aged Fighter Stepped Off A Train In Miami And Into History. This Was The City Where Cassius Clay Became Muhammad Ali.” Sun-Sentinel.